Friday, April 18, 2008

Evangeline - Portland, Maine

Evangeline, located at 190 State Street, opened its doors to the public last evening. The transformation of the space formerly occupied by Uffa is dramatic. A new bar creates a graceful transition between the elevated open kitchen in the rear of the restaurant and the formal seating at the front of the house. Oversized white linen-clad tables and vibrant red banquettes add to the transformation.

Opening night was packed at this French restaurant that seats 30, with eight additional seats at the bar. The music and decor give the restaurant a Parisian ambiance. The energy and laughter from the happy crowd created a sophisticated party mood.

The cork bound wine list was extensive and affordable. Bottles ranged in price from $20-$100, with carafes available for about half the cost of the full bottle. Five reds, five whites and a sparkling wine were available by the glass.

My husband ordered a carafe of 2003 Château de Cruzeau
Bordeaux
, our new favorite White Bordeaux. This Savignon Blanc and Semillon blend was well structured, with a buttery flavor and undertones of citrus. It was so much to our liking, that we quickly requested a full bottle after the first sip.

Memories of Bandol came flooding back when the first "treat" from the kitchen was presented -- a salmon tartar with lemon oil. The zesty lemon hit the taste buds first, cleansing the palate beautifully for the finely diced, fresh salmon that followed. Cubes of focaccia were served with a creamy and flavorful butter which paired wonderfully with the salty bread.

The next "treat" was a white anchovy, set atop a roasted red pepper, and topped with an olive and chive tapenade. My taste buds were singing as the sweet, salty and tart ingredients combined into a harmonious medley of flavors.

My husband's Oyster & Leek Bisque ($9) appetizer, defied the traditional pureed version by keeping the mollusks intact. The salty American caviar nicely contrasted the buttery bisque as the finely diced leek melted in his mouth.

The Mushroom Veloute ($8) was earthy and delicious. The mushroom soup held a mixture of minced mushrooms, shallots and herbs which nicely contrasted the velvety broth. A silky '05 Steele Pinot Noir paired perfectly with this dish. The fruit forward wine had a hint of spice and almond flavors that set off the almond cream in the soup.

The standout dish of the evening was the Orange Duck ($23). A thin layer of fat was left on the seared duck breast. The exterior was crisp, while the tender meat was succulent and moist. Deep ruby colored cara cara oranges were caramelized to perfection and paired with a red endive to create a sweet and savory side. The citrus was subtle in the adorning sauce, sweetened by the caramelization of the winter fruit. This dish was impeccably executed.

I lost my husband's attention as he focused on the fresh cod ($19) which was the basis for a dual preparation. On one side of the plate a gently browned cod filet rested atop of a bed of Aubergine (eggplant) caviar. The other half of the plate contained a pan-fried brandade (a cod and cream mash) that contrasted nicely with the salty olive and sweet pepper topping.

For dessert we shared a Warm Financier ($7), an almond Madeleine-style cake, topped with buttermilk ice cream and a braised cognac-soaked pineapple. This sweet dessert was a perfect ending to the meal.

After witnessing many less graceful grand openings, I was impressed at the staff orchestration. Although you could sense their underlying nervousness at the beginning of the evening, they became increasingly more comfortable with their roles as the night progressed.

For those who enjoyed dining at Erik's former restaurant, Bandol, you will be pleased to once again enjoy his classic French techniques. While he has resurrected several of Bandol's specialty dishes, including the adventurous "Crispy Roasted Calf Brain," the menu is diverse and ripe with numerous innovative creations.

Chef Erik Desjarlais has combined the elegance of distinctively prepared cuisine, with a lively urban setting. An instant classic, Evangeline is a "must try" restaurant for foodies living in, or visiting Portland. A welcome addition to the Longfellow Square neighborhood, Evangeline is destined to become one of the top restaurants in the City.

19 comments:

food said...

i disagree completely. i was there the same night. the food was just ok. the atmo was excellent and so was the service. erik is better than this. i had the duck which was great, the steak was umm regular. he can do better. he needs to increase the entree prices in th 25-30 range and give what he can. this restarant is typical maine... give me more he can be the best chef in a boring same menu scene do it erik please

Erik Desjarlais said...

Thank you, Food. Although we hit some highs in the first few nights of service, I am aware of the lows as well. We're working out kinks. We are trying to not be typical maine. It won't be Bandol, and the first 3 days of service at Bandol were 10X worse than Evangeline's.

Restaurants should never be judged in their first week. It is our job to make note of the lows (the Steak keeps me up at night....as arbitrary as it may sem, there are a LOT of variables in that dish), and get up at 7am to cook and plate it over and over again.

Food, please contact me at ErikDesjarlais@mac.com for more input. It would be greatly appreciated!
Best,
Erik Desjarlais

Erin said...

"Food," I guess we disagree. I returned again Saturday night and had an even better experience. The restaurant has developed its groove...gone was the nervous energy. The Salmon en Papillotte was incredible. Sockeye Salmon was set upon a skillet roasted potato and smothered in tarragon butter, then topped with a bacon vinaigrette...this dish will probably make one of my top food experiences of 2008...I do agree that for this type of cuisine Erik should mark everything on the menu up at least $5. I encourage you to give the restaurant another try.

Miss Bumptious said...

I'm coming in tonight and absolutely can't wait. Erik...feel free not to mark anything up today ;-)

Anonymous said...

I would have to say, while I lived and cooked in NYC for 10 years, I always had a rule to dining at newly opened restaurants....wait 6 months...It is so easy to be critical when a Chef has returned to the scene.....opening night is a night of utter stress, let alone, trying to be perfect...NO ONE is perfect on opening night...and even if they are, someone will find a reason to complain.....give Evangeline some breathing room....

See you in 6 months Eric....from one chef to another.

Anonymous said...

ok, so we went in last night... uuugghh... do we really need fussy french? do we really need a somalier paricularly when the wine list is overly self-explanatory? do we really need pretension? NO NO NO.. our minimal meals
EVENTUALLY came...icy cold, served on icy cold plates in an icy cold room (all the guests were bundled up). I suspect that the brain fritters would be tastier if at least at room temperature. The escargot was tasteless, though I did appreciate their petite size. The cold steak and cold skate were ..O.K.?? There is an obvious knowledge of food but a lack of conscientious preparation to follow through. Plese rethink the essence of what this town could use. Fussy French Fails.. open a bistro style restaurant, beautiful fruit de mer, fresh salade Nicoise, creme brules, cold rose,... a neighborhood cafe that you dine at with regularity for lunch and dinner... sil vous plait

Anonymous said...

Stop telling Erik to mark up his prices!

I want to eat at his place more than once every 6 months... what's wrong with you people?

69.00 per person didn't work at Bandol, and it won't work here either.

AFFORDABLE... and that seems to be what the initial intention is here.

Yum!

Anonymous said...

So, Anonymous...

What do you find to be fussy? How is someone being helpful with an extensive wine list pretentious? You should also learn how to spell. It sounds like you are tragically misinformed and maybe what this town needs is to see less of YOU in restaurants.

scheherazade said...

I ate there for the first time recently and have been mulling over the experience since. Love the look and feel of the room. Found the service and staff earnest and conscientious, and very serious about food. I can see how that seems "pretentious" to some, and in some ways (because I am not particularly serious about food) it was to me. But they were ready with a smile and an explanation so it wasn't condescending, and instead of feeling out of place I just felt like I had some pretty helpful guides to new flavors.

Service was great, and to someone not accustomed to such flair and attention it also at first was disconcerting. But I think the intention and effect was more helpful than showy. Again, I see the tricky line between setting service levels to a cut above ordinary and being branded "pretentious".

So on the whole I felt like I was in a special room, with specialists who love food eager to serve me. The menu was also promising.

The letdown for me was the food. It's probably my fault, is what I concluded, because how could all these good people with such a deliberate approach be wrong? But for the expectations that the atmosphere created for me, I found the food less flavorful and pleasing than I wish I had. (I had the oyster/caviar bisque, elegantly presented but so subtly flavored that it felt fairly bland to me, and the steak frites, while companions had brain fritters, monkfish, and salmon papillote.) The monkfish I had at the Front Room a couple of months ago was better in both flavor and texture. My steak was good, but I guess by the time it came and by the way I'd been impressed by all the other details, I expected it to be among the best steak I'd ever had, and it was only ordinary.

Had a taste of some smoky bacon flavored ice cream, which was worth the price of admission for me. And I loved hearing about the cheeses -- just the descriptions, by an earnest and friendly server, made me wish I had saved room (and made me wish I more regularly tasted cheese).

I concluded after the evening that this place is obviously impressive but not, probably, someplace I'll go back to -- the caliber of the food wasn't up to the "specialness" of the whole rest of the experience.

I also recently went to Five-Fifty-Five after five years, and was newly impressed. It's hard to think of an occasion where I will want a special dinner where I wouldn't choose 555 instead of Evangeline. I'll go back in 6 months, as Anonymous suggested, because I'm rooting for these guys, and wanted to be as smitten by the food as Erin was.

Anonymous said...

Evangeline was sort of hit and miss with us. My wife had the esgargot, one of her loves, she thought the flavor was weak.
She had the duck and liked it but short on size. I had the oysters and the skate. The flavors on the skate were very nice, it was on the bone which was a first for me.
Wine, service great. Will try again for sure.
B.from PI.

Anonymous said...

We dined at Evangeline's a few weeks back. There were six of us so we were able to try a myriad of food. I must say everything was cooked and served beautifully from first course to last but there were no culinary orgasms for anyone at the table.

I also get the whole small portion thing but when I was served three cucumber slice sized portions of Duck with half a brussel sprout and three threads of beet it left me saying, seriously?

It was a fun night but will I go back again? Only if I've eaten a substantial amount of food before I go and someone else is picking up the hefty tab.

Anonymous said...

Erik Desjarlais is the real deal.

Bill and Ro said...

My wife and I from New Jersey and another couple who live in Portland went to Evangeline for New Year's Eve dinner on 12/31/08. We were absolutely blown away by the entire meal and wine pairing, except for the desert (a soggy crepe concoction). We would definitely come back.This place compares favorably with many very nice restaurants in New York City. Bill and Ro

John and Samuel said...

My son - who lives n Portland- and I ate at Evangeline on Saturday night (April 4) and the food was good....BUT we had the chefs menu which was promised to be dishes off the menu. What was served was a melange of dishes from the menu, nothing new and frankly for the $55.00 per person - food only, no wine, I could have had pretty much the same things a la carte. I expect when I have a tasting menu to sample the best of the chefs imagination. There were two of us and we were each served different dishes at each course, there weren't any litle "touches". When we had chefs menus at other restaraunts, there were little special touchs in between courses for example, that elevated the dinner to a new level.
We've eaten at Fore Street, Vignola, 555, Emilitsa, and various other Portland haunts over the past 3 months so we are aware of what's out there. It was oo bad becuaes the service was good, the food was very well prepared but if the result doesn't satisfy the expectation than why bother?

John and Samuel said...

A follow up to my post yesterday. When I said why bother, it wasn't in reference to the food, the dishes were very successful in their preparation- I was referring only to the chefs menu. It is still worth the dining experience.

Alison Cook said...

Had to wonder at the old comment that expressed a preference for 555 over Evangeline. I found the food at 555 to be unfocused and far too busy; whereas the Evangeline kitchen cooked with discipline and clarity of flavors. No contest.

john and Samuel said...

It wasn't a preference of 555 it was a comment regarding the diversity and anticipation of ordering the chefs menu. Each place is different and has their respective strengths and weaknesses. i would like to see more of the chefs character in the chefs menu - thats all. If I wanted food straight off the menu I would have ordered it and probably ended up with the same final total.

I also thought the food at 555 was very focused, what did you have that precipitated your comment?

Anonymous said...

I agree with the focus at Evangeline. The chef is definitely on the mark, and deserves more credit in the news and recognition from the press. Any naysayers have no idea what they are talking about. 555 lacks passion. Corry is not even in his kitchen....Dejarlais actually COOKS in front of a range. I would dine at Evangeline over any other place in town, except his wife's place, of course!
I hear (from a great source) they are working on opening a new place called "12 Seats". 12 seats, and a set menu every night. YAY!!!!! Finally!!

Anonymous said...

Anything new about 12 seats????

Post a Comment